Slide background

Tutti i Documenti presenti nella sezione tematica Macchine

sono elaborati o selezionati dalla nostra redazione su Standards riconosciuti.

Acquista Abbonamento

Stima del rischio con il metodo SCRAM (SICK)

ID 15490 | | Visite: 3908 | Documenti Riservati Direttiva macchinePermalink:

Cover Stima del rischio con il metodo SCRAM

Stima del rischio con il metodo SCRAM (SICK) Rev. 1.0 Settembre 2022

ID 15490 | 16.09.2022 / Documento completo (EN) in allegato

Risk assessment and risk reduction for machinery - Part 3: Conducting risk estimation. Scalable risk analysis and evaluation method (SCRAM)

Update Rev. 1.0 2022




Machine risk assessment consists of a series of steps used to examine the hazards associated with machines and it consists of two stages, namely risk analysis and risk evaluation, as laid out in ISO 12100:2012. Risk analysis comprises three stages: determining the limits of the machine, identifying hazards, and estimating the risk.

After having completed the hazard identification phase, risk estimation is carried out for each identified hazard and hazardous situation. Risk is defined as a combination of the severity of harm and the probability of occurrence of that harm.

According to ISO 12100:2012, the probability of occurrence of harm can be estimated taking into account the frequency and duration of exposure to the hazard, the probability of occurrence of a hazardous event, and the technical and human possibilities to avoid or limit the harm. The combination of the severity of the possible harm with these three probability parameters will be used to estimate risk values which can then be used for comparison purposes. At the last stage of the assessment process, risk evaluation allows decisions on risk reduction measures to be applied to the machine.

The scope of this white paper is to provide a risk estimation methodology that has proved to be robust, and reliable while preventing errors when estimating risks.


This white paper is part of a series of papers describing the SICK process of risk assessment in combination with risk reduction:

- Part 1: Defining the scope of the risk assessment
- Part 2: Identifying task/hazard pairs
- Part 3: Conducting risk estimation
- Part 4: Integrating protective devices into (existing) control systems
- Part 5: Implementing emergency operations
- Part 6: Carrying out substantial modifications

Risk reduction process


All products and systems include hazards and, therefore, some level of risk. However, the risk associated with those hazards shall be reduced to an acceptable or tolerable levela. The iterative process of risk assessment and risk reduction for each task and hazard combination is essential in achieving acceptable risk (level of risk that is accepted in a given context based on the current values of society).

The objective of risk reduction can be achieved by the elimination of significant hazards, or by reducing each of the two elements (separately or simultaneously) that determine the associated risk:

- Severity of harm from the hazard under consideration
- Probability of occurrence of that harm

Stima del rischio con il metodo SCRAM   Figura 1

Fig. 1 - Overall risk reduction

a For the purpose of this document, the terms “acceptable risk” and “tolerable risk” are considered to be synonymous.

Three-step method

All risk reduction measures intended for reaching this objective shall be applied in the following sequence, referred to as the threestep method:


Inherently safe design measures are achieved by avoiding hazards or reducing risks by implementing a suitable choice of design features for the machine itself and/or interaction between the exposed persons and the machine.

Inherently safe design measures are the first and most important step in the risk reduction process. This is because risk reduction measures inherent to the characteristics of the machine are likely to remain effective, whereas experience has shown that even well-designed safeguarding can fail or be defeated and information for use may not be followed.


Guards and protective devices (also known as “safeguarding” or “engineering controls”) shall be used to protect persons whenever an inherently safe design measure does not reasonably make it possible either to remove hazards or to sufficiently reduce risks (for details see chapter “Technical protective measures”). Complementary protective measures involving additional equipment (for example, emergency stop equipment) may also be necessary.


Information for use consists of communication means, such as texts, words, signs, signals, symbols, or diagrams, used separately or in combination to provide information to the user (employer and/or affected persons).

The information shall contain all directions required for safe and intended use of a machine. To achieve this purpose, it shall also inform and warn the user about residual risk.

The information shall indicate, as appropriate, the requirements for additional measures that the user shall implement:

- The possible need for additional guards or protective devices
- The consideration of regular inspections
- The consideration of safe work procedures and training
- The consideration of personal protective equipment

Information for use shall not be a substitute for the correct application of inherently safe design measures, technical protective measures, or complementary protective measures.


Progressive iterations in risk assessment

Stima del rischio con il metodo SCRAM   Figura 2

Stima del rischio con il metodo SCRAM   Figura 3


MSE Mechanical safeguarding equipment
CSE Control-related safeguarding equipment
SIG Information at machine (e.g., signal or signs)
INS Information in instruction handbook
ORG Safe working procedures
PPE Personal protective equipment

M One or a combination of these measures is mandatory for this risk level
HR One or a combination of these measures is highly recommended for this risk level
R One or a combination of these measures is recommended for this risk level as a lower recommendation to an HR recommendation


ANNEX: Examples of the evaluation of harm severity, ANSI B11.0-2019 3rd edition

Stima del rischio con il metodo SCRAM   Annex Part 1

[...] Segue in allegato

Certifico Srl - EN | Rev. 1.0 2022
©Copia autorizzata Abbonati 

Matrice revisioni

Rev. Data  Oggetto Autore
1.0 16.09.2022 SICK AG - WHITE PAPER 2022-05 Certifico Srl
0.0 19.01.2022 --- Certifico Srl

Fonte: SICK


Descrizione Livello Dimensione Downloads
Allegato riservato Stima del rischio con il metodo SCRAM - SICK Rev. 1.0 2022.pdf
Certifico Srl - Rev. 1.0 2022
2400 kB 77
Allegato riservato Stima del rischio con il metodo SCRAM - SICK Rev. 0.0 2022.pdf
Certifico Srl - Rev. 0.0 2022
2553 kB 252

Tags: Direttiva macchine Valutazione Rischi macchine Abbonati Macchine

Articoli correlati

Più letti Direttiva macchine

Set 04, 2022 111850

Regolamento Prodotti da Costruzione (UE) 305/2011 - CPR

Regolamento CPR (UE) 305/2011 Regolamento (UE) N. 305/2011 del Parlamento Europeo e del Consiglio del 9 marzo 2011 che fissa condizioni armonizzate per la commercializzazione dei prodotti da costruzione e che abroga la direttiva 89/106/CEE del Consiglio (Testo rilevante ai fini del SEE) (GU L 88/10… Leggi tutto

Ultimi archiviati Direttiva macchine

Lug 12, 2024 80

Decreto Ministeriale 19 marzo 1980

Decreto Ministeriale 19 marzo 1980 Discipline dei recipienti destinati a contenere birra e/o bevande gassate con immissione di anidride carbonica (GU n. 16 del 17.01.1981) Leggi tutto
Draft standardisation Regulation  EU  2023 1230   Regulation on machinery
Lug 08, 2024 292

Draft standardisation Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 - Regulation on machinery

Draft standardisation Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 - Regulation on machinery ID 22202 | 08.07.2024 Draft standardisation request to the European Committee for Standardization and to the European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization as regards machinery and related products in support… Leggi tutto
Regolamento  UE  2024 1834
Lug 04, 2024 187

Regolamento (UE) 2024/1834

Regolamento (UE) 2024/1834 / Specifiche tecniche ecodesign ventilatori a motore ID 22174 | 04.07.2024 Regolamento (UE) 2024/1834 della Commissione, del 3 luglio 2024, recante modalità di applicazione della direttiva 2009/125/CE del Parlamento europeo e del Consiglio in merito alle specifiche per la… Leggi tutto
Mag 29, 2024 725

Decreto Dirigenziale numero 123 del 20 maggio 2024

Decreto Dirigenziale numero 123 del 20 maggio 2024 ID 21950 | 29.05.2024 Decreto Dirigenziale numero 123 del 20 maggio 2024 - Programma e modalità d'esame per il conseguimento del titolo professionale di ufficiale di navigazione del diporto di 2a classe, ai sensi dell’articolo 4-bis, comma 2,… Leggi tutto